December 20, 2024
Dubai Court Ruling on Crypto Trading: What Is and Isn’t Prop Trading
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- In Case 452/2024 (Criminal Cassation), the Dubai court clarified the distinction between personal and commercial cryptocurrency trading activities.
- Personal trading for investment purposes was exempt from licensing under the virtual asset regulations but required compliance with anti-money laundering regulations (“AML”).
- Commercial trading, including exchanges, custodial services, or intermediaries, requires prior licensing from the Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (“VARA”).
- Failure to comply with AML and licensing requirements can result in severe penalties, including fines or imprisonment.
- This landmark judgment promotes Dubai’s commitment to fostering a clear regulatory ecosystem for virtual assets.
INTRODUCTION
On 20 November 2024, the Dubai Court of Cassation, in Case 452/2024, clarified the legal status of cryptocurrency trading in Dubai. The ruling distinguished personal crypto trading from commercial activities, providing much-needed regulatory clarity in Dubai’s evolving virtual asset landscape.
The Court addressed a crucial question: How does Dubai regulate individual crypto trading, and what separates personal from commercial activities? The decision reinforces Dubai’s global virtual asset hub ambition while ensuring regulatory compliance.
THE RULING
The case involved allegations against individuals trading cryptocurrency without a licence. The Court clarified:
- Personal Trading: Trading strictly for personal accounts without pooling funds or intermediating does not require a licence, provided AML compliance is met.
- Commercial Trading: Activities like operating exchanges, offering custodial services, or facilitating trades for others require VARA licensing.
The Court overturned a prior judgment, affirming personal trading for investment purposes as non-criminal when done in good faith.
PERSONAL TRADING VS COMMERCIAL TRADING IN DUBAI: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
| Category | Personal Trading | Commercial Trading |
| Definition | Trading for personal investment only, with no third-party involvement. | Trading as a business, offering services, or acting as an intermediary. |
| Primary Objective | Build wealth or diversify a portfolio. | Generate revenue or provide virtual asset services. |
| Licensing Requirement | No VARA licence needed if strictly personal (Case 452/2024). | VARA licence required under Dubai Law No. 4 of 2022. |
| Examples of Activities | Buying/selling for personal gain, using regulated platforms. | Running exchanges, managing wallets, or trading on behalf of others. |
| Compliance with Anti-Money Laundering | Follow UAE AML law: trade via VARA-approved platforms, maintain records, perform KYC, report suspicious activities. | Follow UAE AML law: trade via VARA-approved platforms, maintain records, perform KYC, report suspicious activities. |
| Prohibited Activities | Acting as an intermediary, managing others’ funds, or advertising services without a licence. | Acting as an intermediary, managing others’ funds, or advertising services without a licence. |
| Penalties | Fines up to AED 5 million, imprisonment, and platform bans for AML breaches. | Suspension, significant fines, and criminal prosecution for unlicensed activities. |
| Regulatory Authority | VARA for AML compliance. | VARA and UAE SCA for full oversight and licensing. |
| Factors Blurring Lines | Risk increases with high-frequency trading, pooling funds, or unintentional advertising. | Blurred by services offered, trade volumes, and activities generating fees. |
| Risk Exposure | Low risk if strictly personal; higher risk if resembling commercial activities. | High risk with strict penalties for non-compliance. |
| Legal Recommendations | Avoid advertising, trade only for personal use, and keep detailed records | Obtain VARA licensing, seek legal advice, and ensure robust AML programmes. |
IMPLICATIONS OF THE RULING
The ruling brings much-needed clarity to Dubai’s crypto landscape by:
- Empowering Personal Traders: Individuals can trade for personal gain without legal risks, provided they meet AML requirements.
- Strengthening Business Regulations: Commercial activities face strict licensing and compliance, ensuring a secure virtual asset ecosystem.
CONCLUSION
This ruling balances innovation with oversight. Personal traders gain exemptions, while businesses are held accountable under UAE law. It solidifies Dubai’s position as a global leader in crypto regulation, fostering a transparent and robust virtual asset ecosystem.
***
TLP Advisors is a dynamic and forward-thinking consulting, strategy and law firm specialising in providing cutting-edge solutions to our diverse clientele. With our roots deeply embedded in financial services, gaming, web3, and emerging tech, we offer unparalleled knowledge and support tailored to these rapidly evolving sectors’ unique challenges and opportunities.
TLP Advisors has consistently been the firm of choice for L1 chains, DeFi protocols, gaming companies, fintech and payment companies, foundations, funds, and investors. We have built a reputation for excellence through frequent collaborations with regulators, funds, and technology incubators. Our deep understanding of the intricate regulatory landscapes and industry dynamics allows us to provide strategic guidance and innovative solutions that empower our clients to navigate complex challenges and seize emerging opportunities.
***